Former Manchester United midfielder Nemanja Matic has delivered a blistering assessment of current goalkeeper Andre Onana, calling him “one of the worst goalkeepers in Manchester United’s history.” Matic’s comments come just hours before United’s UEFA Europa League quarter-final first-leg tie against French side Lyon.
The Serbian, who played for the Red Devils between 2017 and 2022, was reacting to Onana’s pre-match remarks in which the Cameroon international claimed United were “way better” than Lyon. “You need to have cover to say something like that,” Matic said during his own press conference. “If David de Gea, Peter Schmeichel or Van der Sar said that, then I would question myself. But if you are statistically one of the worst goalkeepers in Manchester United’s modern history, you need to show that before you talk.”
Onana Responds: to Matic Comments “At Least I’ve Lifted Trophies”
Andre Onana did not stay silent following Matic’s harsh words. The 29-year-old Cameroon international responded with a pointed retort, highlighting his recent achievements with Manchester United. “I would never be disrespectful to another club,” he said. “We know tomorrow will be a difficult game. We’re focused on delivering a performance that makes our fans proud.”
In a subtle jab at Matic’s own career, Onana added: “At least I’ve lifted trophies with the greatest club in the world. Some can’t say the same.” Onana helped United secure the FA Cup last season, a silver lining in what has been a turbulent campaign marked by inconsistency and defensive frailties.
Ruben Amorim Calls for Context and Calm
Sporting Lisbon manager Ruben Amorim, speaking at the same pre-match press conference, stepped in to de-escalate the tension surrounding the verbal exchange. While not directly involved in the spat, Amorim emphasized the importance of understanding full context in player comments. “Tomorrow, it will not matter,” he said. “If you see the full quote of Onana, it is quite different. There was no disrespect—just confidence.”
Amorim, who is close to Matic, suggested the veteran may have misinterpreted Onana’s intentions. “I know Matic well. He’s a great guy. Sometimes quotes are heard in part, not whole. That’s what happened here,” he said. He added that Onana was likely just expressing belief in his team, something common in high-stakes football.
Onana’s Performance Under the Microscope
Andre Onana’s debut season at Manchester United has been under intense scrutiny, with critics pointing to a string of high-profile errors and poor statistical records. In 31 Premier League appearances this season, Onana has conceded 41 goals—eighth-most among top-flight goalkeepers. His Europa League stats also paint a grim picture, with ten goals allowed in just eight matches and only one clean sheet.
Since joining United from Inter Milan in 2023, Onana has played 93 matches in all competitions. While his shot-stopping abilities have occasionally impressed, his inconsistency and questionable decision-making have fueled ongoing debates about his long-term suitability for the club. Matic’s comments have now amplified those concerns ahead of a crucial European tie.
All Eyes on Lyon Clash as War of Words Heats Up
As Manchester United prepare to face Lyon in France on Thursday, the war of words between past and present players has added an unexpected subplot to the Europa League quarter-final. With the return leg at Old Trafford set for April 17, Onana will have a golden opportunity to silence his critics and prove he belongs in the elite ranks of United goalkeepers.
Whether Matic’s comments will spur Onana into a commanding performance or further destabilize his form remains to be seen. For manager Erik ten Hag, the priority will be ensuring the goalkeeper remains focused amid the distraction. What is certain, however, is that all eyes will be on the United shot-stopper when the teams line up in Lyon.
